It is not possible to duplicate a gallery created by WP-Juicebox.
You could reuse images (but not a gallery) if the source of images is Flickr, a NextGEN Gallery or a Picasa Web Album but if the gallery is sourced by Media Library images, then, no matter where the images are stored (locally or on Amazon S3), you will need to upload the images again and attach them to the post containing the new gallery.
You could, however, create a gallery on your computer with JuiceboxBuilder-Pro and use the baseUrl method of embedding (documented here) to embed the same gallery in multiple different posts.
Essentially, once you have created a gallery with JuiceboxBuilder-Pro, you would upload the complete gallery folder (not just the contents) to your web server and paste the baseUrl embedding code into the body of your WordPress post (ensuring that the method of entry is 'Text' rather than 'Visual'). It does not matter where on your web server you upload your gallery folder to as long as the two paths in the embedding code (the path to the 'juicebox.js' file and the baseUrl itself, pointing towards the gallery folder) are correct.