Topic: No Crop option

Is there and option for no crop for the thumb nails.  I would like to use juice box for client galleries but having cropped thumbnails kinda defeats the point.  It would force clients to have to view every image individually.  I can here the complaints already.

Re: No Crop option

There is no cropping tool for the thumbnails. However, you can create thumbnail images of whatever size you like in JuiceboxBuilder-Pro by clicking the 'Change Sizes...' button in the 'Image Size' control panel on the 'Images' tab and entering thumb width and thumb height dimensions.
JuiceboxBuilder-Pro will create thumbnails at the specified dimensions and will set the thumbWidth and thumbHeight configuration options (in the gallery's XML file) to the values that you use.

As long as the aspect ratio you use for the thumbnails matches that of your main images, then the thumbnails will not be cropped.

(Please note that all thumbnails in a gallery will have the same dimensions and, if any cropping is required, the thumbnails will be center-cropped.)

Re: No Crop option

That is unfortunate choice, especially since I would think your market would be image creators. Think about it, does any image viewing software (iPhoto, Aperture, Lightroom) do this?  Essentially then unless all my images are exactly the same size (that hasn't occurred in over 20 years but it may some day) then they get randomly center cropped.  Do you understand that this directly works against what most image creators want?  Maybe there are some limitations but other gallery software I use is able to accomplish this.

I don't wish to be overly critical since juice box does so many things well.  However this is something so basic it seem sad that it was not given value.

Re: No Crop option

The thumbnails within a Juicebox gallery were designed more as a navigation device that a way to showcase the main images themselves. Many users choose to use dots instead of thumbnails (to maximize the amount of space for the main images) or not to use thumbnails at all (although I understand that different users have different requirements and this may not suit your own needs).

Please feel free to post suggestions for future versions in the Feature Requests forum thread.
This keeps all the ideas together and ensures that they are not overlooked by the developers. Thank you.

Re: No Crop option

I think there in lies my issue.  If it is a navigation tool it should show where a user would be navigating to, rather than imply it or do it partially.  Think of a road sign that is only 2/3's complete and the only way you can find out what it is completely is to drive down it.  This sign is no longer aiding in navigation but a hindrance.  If I create a gallery for clients that contains 250 images they essentially have to look at every image full size since there is no smaller version, this in effect makes the thumbnails useless and the navigation pointless. 

As someone who has worked in design for 25 years what was the decision process in cropping the images?  How does it make sense as a design element not to show the entire image as a navigation?  To me it seems the code is dictating the design rather than the other way around.  If I use every well know image browser as my design guide why the decision to do it differently from successful examples?   I can completely accept if there is no way to accomplish that. 

I don't mean to be critical, but it was the first thing someone said to me when I sent them a test gallery.  "Oh the thumbnails are cropped that is weird, why did you do that?"  That was there response so basically I'm asking for them.

Re: No Crop option

I understand your concerns and requirements but, unfortunately, I cannot answer your questions directly as I am not the author of Juicebox and I did not make any of the design decisions. I hope you understand.
However, thank you for posting your suggestion in the Feature Requests thread.